Your session is about to expire
Lactulose vs Metamucil
Introduction
For patients dealing with constipation or other bowel issues, certain medications can aid in improving stool consistency and promoting regular bowel movements. Lactulose and Metamucil are two such drugs that are often recommended for managing these symptoms. Each works differently within the digestive tract but both are beneficial in easing discomfort associated with constipation. Lactulose is a synthetic sugar used to treat constipation; it's broken down in the colon into products that pull water out from the body and into the colon, which helps soften stools. On the other hand, Metamucil is a bulk-forming fiber supplement made from psyllium husk which absorbs liquid in your intestines to form a softer, bulky stool that's easier to pass.
Lactulose vs Metamucil Side By Side
| Attribute | Kristalose enulose | Metamucil |
|---|---|---|
| Brand Name | Kristalose, Enulose | Metamucil |
| Contraindications | Bowel obstructions, difficulty swallowing without consulting a healthcare professional | Bowel obstructions, difficulty swallowing without consulting a healthcare professional |
| Cost | $30 - $60 for a 500 mL bottle | $18-$25 for a container containing 114 doses |
| Generic Name | Lactulose | Psyllium husk |
| Most Serious Side Effect | Severe allergic reactions, electrolyte imbalance, dehydration symptoms, rectal bleeding | Signs of an allergic reaction, severe stomach pain, difficulty swallowing, chest pain, vomiting, rectal bleeding, unusual changes in mood or behavior, rapid weight gain |
| Severe Drug Interactions | Not specifically mentioned, but always consult with a healthcare provider for potential interactions | Not specifically mentioned, but always consult with a healthcare provider for potential interactions |
| Typical Dose | 15-60 ml/day for adults | 1-2 rounded teaspoons mixed into at least 8 ounces of liquid, taken up to three times daily |
What is Lactulose?
Lactulose, a synthetic sugar used in treating constipation, is an over-the-counter medication that works by drawing water into the intestine to induce bowel movements. It was first introduced as a prescription drug and has since been considered safe for long-term use. On the other hand, Metamucil, also known as psyllium husk, is a dietary fiber supplement often used to treat constipation and promote regularity. Unlike lactulose which acts directly on the colon, Metamucil bulks up your stool by absorbing liquid in your intestines which promotes movement through the digestive system. While both are effective for alleviating symptoms of constipation, they function differently within our body's digestive tract. Lactulose primarily focuses on increasing water content in stools making them softer and easier to pass while Metamucil adds bulk to stools helping create a more natural rhythm of bowel movements.
What conditions is Lactulose approved to treat?
Lactulose is approved for the treatment of various conditions, including:
- Chronic constipation
- Abnormal brain function due to liver failure (hepatic encephalopathy)
While Metamucil, on the other hand, is used primarily as a fiber supplement and is approved for:
- Dietary management of mild to moderate hypercholesterolemia
- Relief from occasional constipation and to improve regularity.
How does Lactulose help with these illnesses?
Lactulose helps to manage constipation by drawing water into the intestines. It does this by remaining largely undigested until it reaches the colon, where bacteria break it down into substances that pull water from the body into the colon. This increases stool volume and softens it, promoting bowel movement. Regular bowel movements are important for maintaining gut health, which plays a significant role in overall wellbeing, including digestion and absorption of nutrients. Individuals struggling with chronic or occasional constipation may have fewer and harder stools than normal. Therefore, by increasing stool hydration and volume with lactulose, we can limit discomfort related to constipation and help patients manage their condition more effectively.
What is Metamucil?
Metamucil, which is a brand name for psyllium husk, functions as a bulk-forming laxative and fiber supplement. Psyllium husk works by absorbing water in your gut to form a gel-like substance that aids in the passage of stool. It was first approved by the FDA many decades ago and it has been used safely since then for constipation relief.
Unlike lactulose, Metamucil does not work directly on the colon to draw water or change the bacterial flora; instead it increases fecal bulk and moisture content due to its high soluble fiber composition. This makes Metamucil an excellent choice for those looking to treat constipation while also adding more fiber into their diet.
Side effects are unusual if taken at recommended doses but may include bloating or stomach cramps initially as your body adjusts. Also unlike some other types of laxatives such as lactulose, long-term use of Metamucil should not result in an imbalance of electrolytes.
What conditions is Metamucil approved to treat?
Metamucil, a fiber supplement made from psyllium husk, is primarily used to help with bowel regularity and overall digestive health. Here are some of the conditions for which Metamucil can be beneficial:
- Chronic constipation
- Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS)
- High cholesterol levels when used in conjunction with a low-fat diet
How does Metamucil help with these illnesses?
Psyllium, the active ingredient in Metamucil, is a type of fiber that plays multiple roles in maintaining gut health. Similar to how norepinephrine affects wakefulness and focus, psyllium adds bulk to your stool which helps promote movement through your digestive system. This can alleviate symptoms of constipation much like lactulose does. However, unlike lactulose, Metamucil not only softens the stool but also absorbs liquid in the intestines making bowel movements smoother and easier. Additionally, due to its action on bile acids in the gut, it may play a role in lowering cholesterol levels too. It's often prescribed when patients don't respond well to typical laxatives or as an addition to certain diets for managing weight and blood sugar control.
How effective are both Lactulose and Metamucil?
Lactulose and Metamucil (Psyllium) are both widely used as over-the-counter remedies for constipation, albeit they work via different mechanisms. Lactulose is a synthetic sugar that works by softening the stool and increasing bowel movements. On the other hand, Metamucil is a bulk-forming fiber supplement which absorbs liquid in your intestines to create a softer, bulky stool that's easier to pass.
Both products have been extensively studied for their effectiveness in treating constipation. A 2004 review of clinical trial data showed similar efficacy between lactulose and psyllium in treating chronic idiopathic constipation.[1] However, patients' preference tends to lean towards psyllium due to its natural origin compared to the synthetically-produced lactulose.
[1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15290667/
The same study also highlighted an important difference: while both are generally safe with minimal side effects, some users reported bloating or flatulence more frequently with lactulose than with psyllium.[1]
Despite these differences, it should be noted that treatment choice often depends on individual patient needs and responses. For instance, while Metamucil might be preferred due to its natural origins and fewer side effects like bloating or gas; Lactulose could still be beneficial — particularly for elderly populations where harder stools may pose greater issues such as increased risk of anal fissures or hemorrhoids.
In terms of dosages for optimal effectivity: For adults using Psyllium – starting dose can range from one-half teaspoon up three times daily; whereas recommended dosage of Lactulose usually starts at 15ml-30ml per day but can go up depending on response.
For children below six years old though,it’s best consult healthcare provider before administering any medication including laxatives.
[2]https://www.medicinenet.com/psyllium_vs_lactulos/article.htm#what_is_psyllium_what_is_lactulos
Related trials for lactulose and metamucil
Find Top Clinical Trials
Choose from over 30,000 active clinical trials.
At what dose is Lactulose typically prescribed?
Oral dosages of Lactulose range from 15-60 ml/day for adults, but studies have indicated that 30 ml/day is often sufficient to treat constipation in most people. For children, the dosage varies based on age and weight, starting as low as 5 ml per day. In either population, if there is no response after a couple of days, the dosage can be increased gradually under medical supervision. The maximum daily dose should not exceed 60 ml for adults and should always be determined by a healthcare professional for children. On the other hand, Metamucil dosages typically start at one teaspoon (approximately 3.4 grams) mixed with water up to three times per day for both adolescents and adults.
At what dose is Metamucil typically prescribed?
Metamucil treatment typically begins with a dosage of 1-2 rounded teaspoons mixed into at least 8 ounces of liquid, taken up to three times daily. Depending on individual needs and response, the dose can be increased to a maximum of 5 doses per day for adults, each dose spaced approximately 4 hours apart. Each serving should be accompanied by sufficient fluid intake. If there is no improvement or if symptoms persist after a week or two, it may be necessary to discuss other options with your healthcare provider. As always, Metamucil should be used as directed and never exceed the recommended daily dosage without consulting your doctor.
What are the most common side effects for Lactulose?
Common side effects of lactulose include:
- Gas, belching
- Cramps, abdominal discomfort or pain
- Diarrhea (especially at high doses)
- Nausea and vomiting
- Electrolyte imbalance including low potassium levels
On the other hand, common side effects of Metamucil include:
- Bloating
- Stomach cramps
- Gas and increased bowel movements
- Allergic reaction such as rash or itching Remember that both drugs may cause serious problems if taken improperly. Always consult your healthcare provider before starting a new medication.
Are there any potential serious side effects for Lactulose?
While both Lactulose and Metamucil are used to treat constipation, their side effects can differ. In rare cases, taking lactulose may result in:
- Severe allergic reactions characterized by hives, difficulty breathing or swallowing, swelling of the face or throat
- Electrolyte imbalance resulting in muscle cramps or spasms, feeling tired or light-headed, irregular heartbeats
- Dehydration symptoms including extreme thirstiness, decreased urination frequency and dark-colored urine
- Rectal bleeding
On the other hand, using Metamucil might lead to:
- An allergic reaction that could include itching/swelling (particularly of the face/tongue/throat), severe dizziness and trouble breathing.
- Changes in blood sugar levels for people with diabetes
- Bloating
- Gas
In case you experience these symptoms after taking either medication it's crucial to seek immediate medical attention.
What are the most common side effects for Metamucil?
Common side effects for Metamucil can include:
- Bloating, gas or a feeling of fullness
- Stomach cramps
- Nausea or vomiting
- Constipation (if not taken with enough water)
- Allergic reactions - rash, itching/swelling (especially of the face/tongue/throat), severe dizziness, trouble breathing.
Please remember that while some individuals may experience these side effects, others may not. The benefits and risks of any medication should be discussed with your healthcare provider before beginning treatment.
Are there any potential serious side effects for Metamucil?
While Metamucil is generally well-tolerated, there are some rare and serious side effects that you should be aware of. These include:
- Signs of an allergic reaction such as hives, itching, a rash, swelling in your face or throat, difficulty breathing
- Severe stomach pain
- Difficulty swallowing
- Chest pain
- Vomiting
- Rectal bleeding
- Unusual changes in mood or behavior
- Rapid weight gain (especially if you're also experiencing shortness of breath)
If you experience any of these symptoms after taking Metamucil, discontinue use immediately and seek medical attention.
Contraindications for Lactulose and Metamucil?
Both Lactulose and Metamucil, like most other laxative medications, may exacerbate symptoms of digestive discomfort in some individuals. If you notice your constipation worsening or experience severe abdominal pain after starting these treatments, please seek immediate medical attention.
Neither Lactulose nor Metamucil should be taken if you are experiencing certain health conditions such as bowel obstructions or difficulty swallowing without first consulting a healthcare professional. Always inform your physician about all the medications and supplements you're currently taking; this includes over-the-counter drugs and herbal products to prevent potential interactions with Lactulose or Metamucil.
Certain pre-existing conditions might require adjustments in dosage or special precautionary measures before initiating therapy with either of these agents. For instance, diabetics should use lactulose cautiously due to its sugar content while those with phenylketonuria need to avoid using certain formulations of Metamucil that contain phenylalanine.
How much do Lactulose and Metamucil cost?
When it comes to the brand-name versions of these drugs:
- The price for a 500 mL bottle of lactulose, such as Kristalose or Enulose, averages around $30 - $60. Depending on your dose (usually between 15 ml to 45 ml daily), this works out to roughly $1–$4 per day.
- A container containing 114 doses of Metamucil fiber supplement costs approximately $18-$25. If taking the recommended serving size (one rounded teaspoon up to three times per day), this notches in at about $0.16-$0.22/day.
Thus, if you are using higher dosages of Lactulose (i.e., closer towards 45ml/day), then brand-name Metamucil is less expensive on a per-day treatment basis.
For generic versions both Lactulose and Metamucil's active ingredient Psyllium, costs can be significantly lower:
- Generic Lactulose is available in sizes from 10 oz upwards with an approximate cost starting from about $0.40/day for typical dosages.
- Generic Psyllium husk powder starts at very low prices too; even large packs don't exceed about $.20/day depending on your dosage frequency and volume.
As always though, remember that cost shouldn't be the primary consideration when deciding which medication suits your needs best.
Popularity of Lactulose and Metamucil
Lactulose, a synthetic sugar used to treat constipation, was estimated to have been prescribed to about 1.5 million people in the US in 2020. Lactulose accounted for just over 8% of laxative prescriptions in the US. It is particularly helpful for those suffering from chronic idiopathic constipation and has seen a steady increase in usage since it can also be used to help reduce high blood ammonia levels.
On the other hand, Metamucil (psyllium), an over-the-counter bulk-forming fiber supplement used primarily as a laxative, does not require a prescription and therefore exact numbers are hard to determine but sales figures indicate that it's widely consumed by millions across America. Psyllium accounts for approximately 15-20% of all OTC laxatives sold off shelves which suggests its popularity among consumers. Its prevalence has remained relatively stable over the past decade with slight increases due to growing awareness about gut health.
Conclusion
Both lactulose and Metamucil (psyllium) have a long-standing track record in managing constipation, supported by numerous clinical studies indicating their effectiveness. Lactulose is a synthetic sugar that works by softening stools and increasing bowel movements, while Metamucil is a natural fiber supplement that absorbs water to create a softer, bulkier stool. Due to their different mechanisms of action, they are often used under different circumstances.
Lactulose tends to be prescribed for chronic idiopathic constipation or secondary constipation due to conditions such as Parkinson's disease or multiple sclerosis. It can also be used in the management of hepatic encephalopathy. On the other hand, Metamucil would usually be recommended for individuals seeking to increase dietary fiber intake or those with occasional constipation.
Both lactulose and psyllium are available over-the-counter which represents significant cost savings especially for patients who must pay out of pocket. Both may require an adjustment period meaning effects may not be noticeable right away.
The side effect profile between these two agents differs slightly; both being generally well-tolerated but bloating and gas are more common side effects with Metamucil than with lactulose. For both drugs, patients should monitor their bowel movement regularity when starting treatment and consult medical help if there’s no improvement within one week or if symptoms worsen.
Other Trials to Consider
Popular Categories
Popular Guides
Learn More About These Treatments
Refrences
- Howard, N., Tsourounis, C., & Kapusnik-Uner, J. (2001, December). Dietary Supplement Survey of Pharmacists: Personal and Professional Practices. The Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine. Mary Ann Liebert Inc.http://doi.org/10.1089/10755530152755225
- Johnson, D. A. (2006). Treating Chronic Constipation. Clinical Drug Investigation. Springer Science and Business Media LLC.http://doi.org/10.2165/00044011-200626100-00001
- Jouët, P., Sabaté, J. ‐m ., Cuillerier, E., Coffin, B., Lémann, M., Jian, R., & Flourié, B. (2005, October 25). Low‐dose lactulose produces a tonic contraction in the human colon. Neurogastroenterology & Motility. Wiley.http://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2982.2005.00727.x
- Cheng, J., Tennilä, J., Stenman, L., Ibarra, A., Kumar, M., Gupta, K. K., … Ouwehand, A. C. (2019, May 21). Influence of Lactitol and Psyllium on Bowel Function in Constipated Indian Volunteers: A Randomized, Controlled Trial. Nutrients. MDPI AG.http://doi.org/10.3390/nu11051130