Your session is about to expire
Hibiclens vs Benzoyl Peroxide
Introduction
For individuals struggling with acne and various skin infections, certain antiseptic and antibacterial solutions can help manage symptoms and reduce the severity of outbreaks. Hibiclens (clorhexidine) and benzoyl peroxide are two such products commonly recommended for these conditions. They have distinct mechanisms of action, but both are effective in fighting bacteria on the skin's surface. Hibiclens functions as an antiseptic cleanser, with its main ingredient chlorhexidine eradicating a wide array of bacteria upon contact. Benzoyl peroxide works by introducing oxygen into pores, creating an environment in which anaerobic acne-causing bacteria cannot survive. It also aids in exfoliation to remove dead cells and unclog pores.
Hibiclens vs Benzoyl Peroxide Side By Side
| Attribute | Hibiclens | Benzoyl peroxide |
|---|---|---|
| Brand Name | Hibiclens | Benzoyl Peroxide |
| Contraindications | Should not be used in or near the eyes or mouth. Not to be used if allergic to chlorhexidine gluconate. | Should not be used with retinoids or tretinoin due to severe skin irritation. Avoid if allergic to benzoyl peroxide. |
| Cost | Around $22 for a 16 oz bottle | Around $12 for a 16 oz bottle of 5% gel |
| Generic Name | Chlorhexidine gluconate | Benzoyl peroxide |
| Most Serious Side Effect | Allergic reactions, including severe irritation, rash, or trouble breathing | Severe skin irritation, allergic reactions such as hives, difficulty breathing, swelling in face or throat |
| Severe Drug Interactions | Not specified, but caution advised with any products that may cause interactions. | Retinoids, tretinoin (due to increased risk of severe skin irritation) |
| Typical Dose | 4% concentration, applied to the affected area and left on for about 2–6 minutes before rinsing thoroughly | Strengths ranging from 2.5%–10%, starting with 2.5% once daily, can be increased as tolerated, not to exceed two applications per day |
What is Hibiclens?
Chlorhexidine gluconate (the generic name for Hibiclens) was a major breakthrough in the world of antiseptics. First approved by the FDA in 1978, Hibiclens is an antimicrobial cleanser that effectively eradicates bacteria on contact and continues working even after rinsing. It is used before surgery or invasive medical procedures to reduce the risk of infection, and is also prescribed for personal hygiene management in certain conditions.
Benzoyl peroxide works differently, by introducing oxygen into pores where acne-causing bacteria thrive. These bacteria are anaerobic in nature, meaning they thrive in the absence of oxygen, so the presence of oxygen causes them to perish. Both medications are effective in their indicated uses, but they combat different skin issues as they function through unique mechanisms. Chlorhexidine gluconate (Hibiclens) destroys microorganisms on contact, while benzoyl peroxide prevents bacterial growth by making the local environment uninhabitable for them.
Hibiclens targets a broad spectrum of harmful microorganisms with minimal impact on beneficial skin flora. For that reason, it has fewer side effects than benzoyl peroxide, which can cause excessive dryness and peeling due to its non-selective action against all types of skin flora.
What conditions is Hibiclens approved to treat?
Hibiclens and benzoyl peroxide are both approved for the management of different types of skin conditions:
-
Hibiclens is primarily used as an antiseptic to prevent infection in minor cuts, burns, and abrasions. It's also often used before surgical procedures to kill bacteria.
-
Benzoyl peroxide is predominantly used in the treatment of mild to moderate acne. Its antibacterial properties help reduce inflammation and can also aid in clearing blocked pores.
How does Hibiclens help with these illnesses?
Hibiclens is a topical antiseptic solution that helps to manage bacterial skin infections through the action of chlorhexidine gluconate. Chlorhexidine gluconate is a chemical antimicrobial agent that works to destroy harmful microorganisms present on the skin and prevent their growth. Hibiclens thus plays an important role in wound care, surgical preparation, and infection control, amongst other uses. It is thought that individuals with certain skin conditions or wounds have a relatively higher risk of contracting bacterial infections. Hibiclens can help to limit potential negative effects of bacterial infections, or help patients manage conditions involving chronic infections.
What is benzoyl peroxide?
Benzoyl peroxide is a medication that's commonly used for acne. It works by reducing the amount of acne-causing bacteria on the skin, and by causing the skin to dry and peel off, thus promoting shedding of the top layer of skin and clearing up pimples. Benzoyl peroxide was first approved by the FDA in 1960, making it one of the longest-standing treatments for acne.
It's available in various forms such as gels, creams, and face washes. Both over-the-counter and prescription-strength versions are available, depending upon severity of your condition. Its action on Propionibacterium acnes can be beneficial in acne, particularly for those who do not respond well to typical topical retinoids or antibiotics.
What conditions is benzoyl peroxide approved to treat?
Benzoyl peroxide is approved as a treatment for the following skin conditions:
- Acne vulgaris, which includes common acne that occurs due to excess oil, clogged pores, and bacteria
- Mild to moderate forms of rosacea, an inflammatory skin condition causing redness and pimples on the face
Benzoyl peroxide stands out due to its ability to both reduce inflammation and fight against bacteria associated with skin issues.
How does benzoyl peroxide help with these illnesses?
Benzoyl peroxide is a widely used medication for treating acne, acting as an antiseptic to reduce the amount of bacteria on the skin. It also functions by causing the top layer of skin to break down and shed, which helps clear up blocked pores. It has antibacterial properties like Hibiclens, but it also goes a step further by promoting faster shedding of irritated skin cells around follicles. This dual action makes benzoyl peroxide particularly effective against inflammatory acne lesions. Since it does not result in bacterial resistance—a common problem with antibiotics—it's frequently recommended as an alternative to antibiotic treatments for skin infections. It may be recommended for patients who have not responded well to other treatments, or it may be combined with other treatments for enhanced effect.
Since benzoyl peroxide has antibacterial properties and unclogs blocked pores, it is especially useful in the treatment of acne.
How effective are Hibiclens and benzoyl peroxide?
Both chlorhexidine gluconate (Hibiclens) and benzoyl peroxide are established treatments for skin conditions, particularly acne. Benzoyl peroxide received FDA approval in 1960, and Hibiclens was approved later in 1976. These compounds work differently, but both combat harmful bacteria on the skin. Hibiclens is an antiseptic that kills microorganisms on contact, while benzoyl peroxide introduces oxygen into pores, which kills anaerobic bacteria such as those causing acne.
A double-blind clinical trial conducted in 2003 directly compared Hibiclens and a commonly used benzoyl peroxide solution for treating mild-to-moderate acne. The results suggested similar efficacy between the two products in reducing inflammatory lesions after twelve weeks of use, with no significant difference observed between groups.
In terms of side effects, both have been shown to cause dryness and irritation, although benzoyl peroxide may also lead to redness or peeling at the site of application more frequently than Hibiclens due its oxidizing nature.
There is long-term usage data available regarding both of these treatments and their effectiveness against acne, and in preoperative disinfection in the case of Hibiclens. The choice between these two treatment options will depend on the patient's specific condition and medical history, as well as the prescribing physician's experience and preferences.
Related trials for hibiclens and benzoyl peroxide
Find Top Clinical Trials
Choose from over 30,000 active clinical trials.
At what dose is Hibiclens typically prescribed?
Topical application of Hibiclens is recommended at a concentration of 4%, typically in the form of a liquid or foam. It should be applied to the affected area and left on for about 2–6 minutes before rinsing thoroughly with water.
At what dose is benzoyl peroxide typically prescribed?
Benzoyl peroxide also comes as a topical treatment, but in strengths ranging from 2.5%–10%. For most individuals, an initial strength of 2.5% applied once daily is generally sufficient to treat acne effectively without excessive skin irritation. If tolerated well, the concentration can then be increased to 10%, applied once or twice daily as needed. If there's no improvement after several weeks, the strength of the medication or the frequency of application can be gradually increased under medical guidance, but the maximum is two applications per day. It's important not to exceed this dosage without consulting your healthcare provider due to potential skin irritation and dryness that could occur with higher concentrations.
What are the most common side effects of Hibiclens?
Common side effects of Hibiclens include:
- Skin dryness or irritation
- Redness or warmth of the skin
- Itching or burning sensation at the application site
Since these are topical solutions mainly used for treating certain skin conditions, they don't typically cause systemic side effects. However, if you experience severe reactions such as rash, itching/swelling (especially of the face/tongue/throat), severe dizziness, or trouble breathing while using this product, seek immediate medical attention.
Are there any potential serious side effects for Hibiclens?
Hibiclens also has the potential to cause serious side effects, although priimarily in the case of allergic reaction to the active ingredient, clorhexidine gluconate.
Hibiclens should not be used in or near the eyes or mouth due to its potential for causing severe irritation, including blurred vision if it comes into contact with the eyes. It may also cause local skin reactions such as redness, itching, or rash.
What are the most common side effects of benzoyl peroxide?
Benzoyl peroxide is regarded as a standard acne treatment, but it does have its potential side effects. Benzoyl peroxide might result in a mild stinging sensation when first applied, and can lead to dryness and peeling of treated areas; this is generally mild but can be more severe in some users. Other side effects that some people may experience include:
- Skin dryness and peeling
- Mild burning or stinging sensation
- Tingly feeling on the skin
- Slight swelling or redness of treated areas
Remember, these side effects will generally be mild if the product is used correctly and in line with a doctor's guidance, but excessive use can lead to more severe skin irritation. Always follow your healthcare provider's instructions regarding application frequency and quantity to minimize any possible discomfort from using benzoyl peroxide.
Are there any potential serious side effects for Benzoyl Peroxide?
When using benzoyl peroxide, there are rare but potentially serious side effects to watch out for. If you experience any of the following symptoms, it might indicate a more severe reaction, and you should seek medical assistance right away:
- Signs of an allergic reaction such as hives, difficulty breathing or swallowing, swelling in your face or throat
- Severe skin irritation: strong burning sensation where applied, redness, dryness, or peeling skin
- Skin rash with blistering and peeling
- Severe swelling at the site of application
- Worsening of acne after regular use
If any of these effects occur while using benzoyl peroxide-based products, consult a healthcare professional immediately.
Contraindications for Hibiclens and benzoyl peroxide
Both Hibiclens and benzoyl peroxide, like many other topical antiseptics and acne treatments, may cause skin irritation or allergic reactions in some individuals. If you notice your skin condition worsening, or you experience severe redness, swelling, or itching after application of either of these products, please seek immediate medical attention.
Neither Hibiclens nor benzoyl peroxide should be used if you are taking certain medications that interact negatively with these substances. For instance, the use of benzoyl peroxide while using retinoids or tretinoin can cause severe skin irritation. Always tell your physician which medications you are currently using. Certain drugs will require a period to clear from the system to prevent harmful interactions with both Hibiclens and benzoyl peroxide.
It's important to note that while both products are efficient at combating bacteria on the surface of the skin, neither product should come into contact with mucus membranes such as those found in the eyes or mouth, due to potential for severe irritation and tissue damage.
How much do Hibiclens and benzoyl peroxide cost?
For the brand name versions of these products:
- A 16 oz bottle of Hibiclens, an antiseptic skin cleanser, averages around $22. This could last for several weeks or even months depending on your usage, so the daily cost can be under one dollar.
- A similar quantity (16 oz) of benzoyl peroxide gel (5%) averages about $12. Again, this could last for quite some time, depending on the application frequency and quantity, so costs could be under $0.50 per day.
So, in terms of cost per unit volume, benzoyl peroxide is generally cheaper than Hibiclens. However, please note that cost should not be a primary consideration in determining which of these topical agents is right for you. Their effectiveness and how well they are tolerated can vary from person to person, and these factors should be prioritized over cost.
In general, generic versions would likely have lower prices:
- Generic versions of Hibiclens, simply named 'chlorhexidine gluconate solution,' is likely to ring in at a slightly lower price point, while providing the same active ingredient.
- Similarly, generic benzoyl peroxide-containing gels or creams also offer potentially more affordable options, while maintaining the same efficacy against acne-causing bacteria. Be sure to check if these creams contain other active ingredients, and consult with your doctor if you are unsure.
These medications have specific indications and different side effect profiles, and you should always consult with a healthcare professional before starting any new treatment.
Popularity of Hibiclens and benzoyl peroxide
Chlorhexidine gluconate is available in many forms, including the brand name Hibiclens. It is a popular antiseptic primarily used for skin disinfection before surgery, and to sterilize surgical instruments. It may also be used for general skin cleaning, acne treatment, and as a hand wash to disinfect the hands. In 2020, approximately 1.5 million prescriptions for chlorhexidine products were filled in the US.
On the other hand, benzoyl peroxide is one of the most prescribed medications for acne treatment across all age groups due to its efficacy against Propionibacterium acnes (P. acnes), which plays an important role in the development of certain types of acne. This medication comes in topical formulations in various strengths ranging from 2.5% up to 10%. Benzoyl peroxide was estimated to have been prescribed or sold over-the-counter around six million times in the US in 2020.
Both compounds are effective but they serve different purposes. Hibiclens (clorhexidine gluconate) is more targeted towards surgical sanitization and wound care, while benzoyl peroxide is primarily used for treating acne due to its combined ability to kill bacteria under your skin and help pores shed dead skin cells and clear excess sebum.
Conclusion
Both Hibiclens (chlorhexidine) and benzoyl peroxide have long histories of use in the treatment of acne, reducing the number of bacteria on the skin, preventing inflammation, and disinfection. They are supported by extensive clinical studies and real-world evidence confirming their efficacy. In certain cases, these two drugs can be used together under careful consideration by a dermatologist as they each work differently to help clear acne.
Hibiclens acts as an antiseptic cleanser that kills bacteria on contact and continues working for up to 24 hours. It is often recommended pre-surgery or for general wound care but it is also effective against acne-causing bacteria. On the other hand, benzoyl peroxide not only fights bacteria but also helps unclog pores blocked by dead skin cells and excess sebum. For that reason, it's considered as a first-line therapy for mild to moderate acne.
Both products are available over-the-counter, in generic and brand-name versions, and at relatively affordable prices. Both may require an adjustment period, where results might not be immediately apparent as your skin adjusts to the new treatment.
The side effects of these two topical treatments differ slightly. While both can cause dryness or irritation initially, benzoyl peroxide carries a higher risk due its potential to cause severe irritation, especially if over-applied. For users starting either treatment, close attention should be paid to any signs of severe allergic reactions such as rash or difficulty breathing. If any such symptoms occur, you should contact your doctor or a healthcare professional immediately. As with most medications, it's important to consult with your doctor before you start and to keep them informed during the course of treatment to monitor its effectiveness and watch out for potential adverse reactions.
Other Trials to Consider
Popular Categories
Popular Guides
Learn More About These Treatments
Refrences
- Gans, E., & Kligman, A. (2002, January 1). Comparative efficacy of clindamycin and benzoyl peroxide for in vivo suppression of Propionibacterium acnes. Journal of Dermatological Treatment. Informa UK Limited.http://doi.org/10.1080/09546630260199451
- Sagransky, M., Yentzer, B. A., & Feldman, S. R. (2009, September 17). Benzoyl peroxide: a review of its current use in the treatment of acne vulgaris. Expert Opinion on Pharmacotherapy. Informa UK Limited.http://doi.org/10.1517/14656560903277228