Your session is about to expire
Excedrin vs Ibuprofen
Introduction
For patients experiencing pain, tension headaches or migraines, certain drugs that inhibit the production of prostaglandins - substances in the body associated with pain and inflammation - can provide relief. Excedrin and Ibuprofen are two such medications often recommended for these conditions. Both work to reduce the presence of prostaglandins but achieve this through different combinations of active ingredients. Excedrin is a combination drug containing aspirin, acetaminophen, and caffeine designed to target pain from multiple angles. Aspirin and acetaminophen reduce fever and relieve mild to moderate pain while caffeine enhances their effects by reducing blood flow to certain areas within the brain thereby easing pressure. On the other hand, ibuprofen acts as a nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID), primarily affecting levels of prostaglandins throughout your entire body rather than focusing on specific areas.
Excedrin vs Ibuprofen Side By Side
| Attribute | Excedrin | Ibuprofen |
|---|---|---|
| Brand Name | Excedrin | Ibuprofen |
| Contraindications | Excessive alcohol use, liver disease, prolonged use leading to increased heart rate, high blood pressure, potential stomach ulcers | Excessive alcohol use, liver disease, risk of stroke or heart attack especially in individuals with existing heart disease, gastrointestinal issues like stomach ulcers |
| Cost | Around $10 for 100 caplets | About $7 for 100 tablets (200 mg each) |
| Generic Name | Acetaminophen/Aspirin/Caffeine | Ibuprofen |
| Most Serious Side Effect | Symptoms of an allergic reaction, severe nausea, vomiting or stomach pain, bloody or tarry stools, coughing up blood or vomit that looks like coffee grounds, shortness of breath, rapid heart rate, feeling light-headed, liver problems, overuse headaches, Reye's syndrome | Signs of an allergic reaction, severe skin reactions, kidney issues, liver problems, unusual changes in mood or behavior, rapid weight gain, shortness of breath |
| Severe Drug Interactions | Not specified in the article | Not specified in the article |
| Typical Dose | 1-2 tablets every six hours, not to exceed 8 tablets in a 24-hour period | 200–400 mg every 4 to 6 hours, not to exceed 3200 mg under medical supervision |
What is Excedrin?
Excedrin is a mixed drug that brings together acetaminophen, aspirin, and caffeine to form an effective pain reliever. This combination was introduced as a major advancement on previous single-ingredient analgesics. Excedrin works by addressing different aspects of the body's pain response: acetaminophen helps relieve pain at the source, aspirin reduces inflammation, and caffeine enhances the effectiveness of these two other ingredients. It is prescribed for various types of mild to moderate headaches (like tension headaches), migraines, and bodily discomforts.
On the other hand, ibuprofen acts primarily by inhibiting prostaglandins synthesis – compounds associated with inflammation and pain in the body. Therefore it has anti-inflammatory properties along with its analgesic effects making it effective against conditions involving inflammation such as arthritis or injury-related pains.
In terms of side-effects; while both could potentially cause gastrointestinal disturbances if used excessively or without proper food intake, Excedrin might have additional side effects due to its caffeine content which includes symptoms like restlessness or sleep disturbances.
What conditions is Excedrin approved to treat?
Excedrin is approved for the treatment of several types of pain:
- Headache, including tension headaches and migraines
- Minor aches and pains associated with colds or flu
- Musculoskeletal pain such as that from strains, sprains or mild arthritis
- Pain related to menstrual cramps.
It's important to note that Excedrin is a combination medication containing aspirin, acetaminophen, and caffeine while ibuprofen is a nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID) used on its own.
How does Excedrin help with these illnesses?
Excedrin manages pain and headaches by combining the actions of acetaminophen, aspirin, and caffeine. Acetaminophen works by inhibiting a particular enzyme in the brain that's involved in producing prostaglandins which are chemicals released during injury or illness and cause inflammation and pain. Aspirin is an NSAID (nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug) that also reduces production of prostaglandins throughout the body to reduce inflammation, fever, and relieve mild to moderate pain. The addition of caffeine helps narrow blood vessels in the brain to further alleviate headache symptoms while also enhancing the effectiveness of both acetaminophen and aspirin.
Ibuprofen on the other hand primarily acts as a non-selective inhibitor of cyclooxygenase enzymes (COX-1 & COX-2), reducing production of prostaglandins which consequently relieves pain, reduces inflammation, decreases high temperature in fevers. Therefore Excedrin may provide broader relief due its combination ingredients compared with Ibuprofen but choice between them should consider individual health conditions and potential side effects.
What is Ibuprofen?
Ibuprofen, known by several brand names such as Advil and Motrin, is a type of non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID) that works by inhibiting the production of prostaglandins, substances in our body responsible for pain and inflammation. Ibuprofen was first approved by the FDA in 1974. Unlike Excedrin which is a combination of acetaminophen, aspirin and caffeine primarily used to treat headaches or migraines; ibuprofen's broader action makes it effective not only for headache relief but also for alleviating other types of pain like menstrual cramps, toothaches and reducing fever.
The side-effect profile of ibuprofen differs from that of combined drugs like Excedrin: it doesn't contain any stimulants like caffeine so you're less likely to experience symptoms related to nervousness or sleeplessness. However, compared with combination medications such as Excedrin, there's an increased risk with NSAIDs like ibuprofen for gastrointestinal issues including ulcers or bleeding if used long-term or at high doses. Nevertheless, its wide-ranging effects on managing various forms of pain make it a versatile option especially for those who prefer single-drug treatments over combination ones.
What conditions is Ibuprofen approved to treat?
Ibuprofen is a nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID) which has been approved for the treatment of various conditions such as:
- Minor to moderate pain, associated with headaches, dental pain, menstrual cramps, muscle aches or minor injury
- Fever reduction
- Inflammation and swelling caused by conditions like rheumatoid arthritis and osteoarthritis.
How does Ibuprofen help with these illnesses?
Ibuprofen, like Excedrin, is a medication used to alleviate pain and reduce inflammation in the body. It works by inhibiting the production of prostaglandins, substances that our bodies produce in response to illness and injury. Prostaglandins cause pain and swelling; by reducing their levels, ibuprofen helps mitigate these symptoms. Unlike Excedrin which contains a combination of acetaminophen, aspirin and caffeine geared towards combating headaches specifically (and may bring about unwanted side effects such as jitteriness due to its caffeine content), Ibuprofen has broader anti-inflammatory applications making it suitable for various types of pain including muscle ache or soreness. Furthermore, because it does not contain aspirin (which can irritate the stomach lining), ibuprofen might be preferred for those with sensitive stomachs or who are at risk of gastrointestinal complications.
How effective are both Excedrin and Ibuprofen?
Both Excedrin and ibuprofen are over-the-counter medications that have long histories of efficacy in treating pain, with initial FDA approvals spanning back several decades. While they both serve to mitigate pain, their active ingredients differ which may influence the circumstances under which they are prescribed or chosen by patients. For instance, Excedrin is a combination drug containing acetaminophen (paracetamol), aspirin, and caffeine while ibuprofen is a nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID) on its own.
The effectiveness of Excedrin and ibuprofen in alleviating headache was examined directly in a double-blind clinical trial in 2007; the two drugs displayed comparable abilities to manage symptoms of tension headaches as well as similar safety profiles. In this study, no significant differences were observed between patients receiving either treatment option when considering measures such as reduction of headache intensity or relief from associated symptoms like photophobia.
A review conducted in 1996 showed that ibuprofen starts relieving symptoms quickly after administration and has side effects comparable to other NSAIDs. This report also noted that it's one of the most commonly used over-the-counter analgesics worldwide due to its wide availability and affordability.
Meanwhile, a 2015 meta-analysis indicated that Excedrin seems more effective than placebo for treating migraines but results were mixed when compared against other common treatments including single-ingredient NSAIDs like ibuprofen. Despite these findings, Excedrin remains popular due to its unique composition which provides multi-symptom relief - not just addressing pain but also helping with associated issues like nausea or light sensitivity often seen with migraines.
Related trials for excedrin and ibuprofen
Find Top Clinical Trials
Choose from over 30,000 active clinical trials.
At what dose is Excedrin typically prescribed?
Oral dosages of Excedrin for adults and adolescents typically start at 1-2 tablets every six hours, not to exceed 8 tablets in a 24-hour period. However, studies have shown that even one tablet can be effective for relieving headaches or migraines in some individuals. For children under the age of twelve, use and dose must be determined by a doctor. If relief is not achieved after several doses, it may suggest that an alternative therapy might be needed. Please note that exceeding the recommended daily dosage could lead to potential liver damage due to its acetaminophen content.
At what dose is Ibuprofen typically prescribed?
Ibuprofen treatment typically begins with a dosage of 200–400 mg every 4 to 6 hours, depending on the severity of pain or fever. The dose can be increased if required but should not exceed a maximum of 1200 mg per day for self-care and up to 3200 mg under medical supervision. This medication is usually taken in doses spread evenly throughout the day, not spaced more than six hours apart. If there is no response or insufficient relief from symptoms at the initial dose after a few dosages, you may consult your healthcare provider regarding an increase in dosage or frequency.
What are the most common side effects for Excedrin?
Common side effects of Excedrin can include:
- Nervousness
- Dizziness
- Insomnia (difficulty sleeping)
- Rapid heart rate or palpitations
- Tremors (uncontrollable shaking)
- Nausea and/or vomiting
- Stomach discomfort or pain, which could be signs of gastritis or peptic ulcers
- Diarrhea
- Loss of appetite
- Increased sweating A serious but rare side effect is ringing in the ears.
On the other hand, common side effects of ibuprofen are usually less severe and can include:
-Nausea or vomiting -Stomach upset, constipation, diarrhea, gas. -Dizziness, headache. -Nervousness.
Remember to seek immediate medical attention if you experience any unusual symptoms after taking either medication.
Are there any potential serious side effects for Excedrin?
Excedrin, while generally considered safe for use, can cause serious side effects in rare cases. These may include:
- Symptoms of an allergic reaction: hives; difficult breathing; swelling of your face, lips, tongue or throat.
- Severe nausea, vomiting or stomach pain
- Bloody or tarry stools
- Coughing up blood or vomit that looks like coffee grounds (indicative of internal bleeding)
- Shortness of breath
- Rapid heart rate
- Feeling light-headed (like you might pass out) In case these symptoms appear after taking Excedrin: Liver problems - loss of appetite, upper stomach pain, tiredness, dark urine and jaundice (yellowing of the skin and eyes). Overuse headaches - a headache that is not relieved by medication. Reye's syndrome - sudden changes in behavior with nausea and vomiting followed by rapid deterioration.
If you experience any such symptoms when using Excedrin stop taking it immediately and seek medical attention without delay.
What are the most common side effects for Ibuprofen?
Ibuprofen, when compared to Excedrin, may cause its own set of side effects. Some potential ones include:
- Stomach discomfort or heartburn
- Nausea and vomiting
- Constipation or diarrhea
- Headaches and dizziness
- Ringing in the ears (tinnitus)
- Rash or itchiness
- Shortness of breath
- Fatigue and sleep disturbances.
It's important to note that while ibuprofen is effective at relieving pain, inflammation, and fever due to its nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID) properties, it should be taken with caution if you have a history of stomach ulcers or other gastrointestinal issues as it can exacerbate these conditions. Always consult your healthcare provider for personalized advice regarding medication use.
Are there any potential serious side effects for Ibuprofen?
When using Ibuprofen, one must be aware of potential serious side effects. Though rare, these can include:
- Any signs of an allergic reaction such as hives, difficulty breathing or swallowing, swelling in your face or throat
- Severe skin reactions like a rash that spreads and causes blistering and peeling
- Symptoms related to kidney issues including changes in the amount of urine
- Signs indicative of liver problems: nausea, upper stomach pain, itching, tired feeling, flu-like symptoms loss of appetite dark urine clay-colored stools jaundice (yellowing of the skin or eyes)
- Unusual changes in mood or behavior such as confusion or agitation
- Rapid weight gain especially in the face and midsection
- Shortness of breath even with mild exertion;
If you experience any of these symptoms while taking Ibuprofen it's imperative to stop use immediately and consult with your healthcare provider right away.
Contraindications for Excedrin and Ibuprofen?
Both Excedrin and Ibuprofen, like most other over-the-counter pain relievers, may worsen certain health conditions. If you notice any increase in stomach pain, heartburn symptoms or any unusual bleeding or bruising while taking these medications, please seek immediate medical attention.
Neither Excedrin nor Ibuprofen should be taken if you are consuming alcohol excessively or have been diagnosed with liver disease. Always inform your physician about all the medications and supplements you are currently taking; this is to prevent dangerous interactions with other drugs.
Excedrin contains a combination of acetaminophen (Tylenol), aspirin and caffeine which can lead to unwanted side effects such as increased heart rate, high blood pressure and potential stomach ulcers when used for prolonged periods. On the other hand, long-term use of ibuprofen can cause kidney damage and increase the risk of stroke or heart attack especially in individuals with existing heart disease.
It's essential to remember that even though Excedrin and Ibuprofen are available without prescription they should be used responsibly under professional guidance.
How much do Excedrin and Ibuprofen cost?
For the brand name versions of these drugs:
- The price for a package of 100 Excedrin Migraine caplets averages around $10, which works out to approximately $0.30–$0.60/day, depending on your dose.
- The price for a bottle of 100 Ibuprofen tablets (200 mg each) is about $7, averaging roughly $0.20-$0.40/day.
Thus, if you are in the higher dosage range for Excedrin (i.e., up to two pills every six hours), then brand-name Ibuprofen is less expensive on a per-day treatment basis. Please note that cost should not be a primary consideration in determining which of these drugs is right for you.
For generic versions of both medications:
- Generic Excedrin equivalents contain acetaminophen/aspirin/caffeine and are available at slightly lower prices than the branded version with costs ranging from as low as about $0.15 per day.
- Similarly, generic ibuprofen can range from just over pennies per tablet upwards; even at maximum OTC dosages (1200mg or six x 200mg tablets daily), this rarely exceeds about $.30/day.
Keep in mind that both medications have different active ingredients and mechanisms - always consult healthcare professionals regarding appropriate use based on symptoms and personal health conditions.
Popularity of Excedrin and Ibuprofen
Excedrin, a combination of acetaminophen, aspirin and caffeine, is a popular over-the-counter medication used for the relief of headaches and migraines. In 2020, Excedrin was estimated to have been purchased by approximately 2 million people in the US. It has also been shown effective in treating pain from tension headaches and menstrual cramps.
On the other hand, ibuprofen remains one of the most widely-used non-prescription drugs in America due to its effectiveness against a range of conditions such as fever, inflammation and various types of pain including dental pain. It was estimated that Ibuprofen was used by nearly 20% of American adults monthly according to data from 2020. The popularity of ibuprofen can be attributed to its wide availability as well as being on WHO’s List of Essential Medicines.
Conclusion
Both Excedrin and Ibuprofen have long-standing records of usage in patients for pain relief, and are backed by numerous clinical studies indicating that they are more effective than placebo treatments. In some cases, the drugs may be combined, but this is subject to careful consideration by a physician as they can interact with each other. Due to their different mechanisms of action, with ibuprofen acting primarily as an NSAID (Non-Steroidal Anti-Inflammatory Drug) inhibiting enzymes responsible for inflammation and pain; while Excedrin is a combination drug containing acetaminophen (a mild analgesic), aspirin (an NSAID), and caffeine (which enhances the effect of pain relievers), they tend to be prescribed under different circumstances.
Excedrin is often used for headaches, including migraines due its specific formulation targeted towards these conditions whereas ibuprofen would usually be considered for general body pains like menstrual cramps or muscle strain. Both drugs are available over-the-counter which provides cost savings especially for patients who must pay out of pocket.
The side effect profile is similar between the two drugs, both being generally well-tolerated although gastrointestinal problems such as stomach ulcers can occur especially if taken on an empty stomach or in high doses. For both drugs, patients must monitor any unusual symptoms when starting treatment and should seek medical help immediately if they notice signs of allergic reactions such as hives or difficulty breathing.
Other Trials to Consider
Popular Categories
Popular Guides
Learn More About These Treatments
Refrences
- Anneken, K., Evers, S., & Husstedt, I. W. (2010, March 15). Efficacy of fixed combinations of acetylsalicyclic acid, acetaminophen and caffeine in the treatment of idiopathic headache: a review. European Journal of Neurology. Wiley.http://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-1331.2009.02922.x
- Fiebich, B. L., Lieb, K., Hüll, M., Aicher, B., van Ryn, J., Pairet, M., & Engelhardt, G. (2000, October). Effects of caffeine and paracetamol alone or in combination with acetylsalicylic acid on prostaglandin E2 synthesis in rat microglial cells. Neuropharmacology. Elsevier BV.http://doi.org/10.1016/s0028-3908(00)00045-9
- Royer, G. L., Seckman, C. E., & Welshman, I. A. (1984, July). Safety Profile: Fifteen Years of Clinical Experience with Ibuprofen. The American Journal of Medicine. Elsevier BV.http://doi.org/10.1016/s0002-9343(84)80015-7
- Janssen, G. M. E., & Venema, J. F. (1985, January). Ibuprofen: Plasma Concentrations in Man. Journal of International Medical Research. SAGE Publications.http://doi.org/10.1177/030006058501300110
- Goldstein, J., Silberstein, S. D., Saper, J. R., Ryan, R. E., Jr., & Lipton, R. B. (2006, February 22). Acetaminophen, Aspirin, and Caffeine in Combination Versus Ibuprofen for Acute Migraine: Results From a Multicenter, Double‐Blind, Randomized, Parallel‐Group, Single‐Dose, Placebo‐Controlled Study. Headache: The Journal of Head and Face Pain. Wiley.http://doi.org/10.1111/j.1526-4610.2006.00376.x