Your session is about to expire
Pramoxine vs Lidocaine
Introduction
For patients experiencing pain, itchiness, or irritation from minor skin conditions like burns, insect bites, or hemorrhoids, there are specific drugs that can provide temporary relief by numbing the nerve endings in the skin. Pramoxine and Lidocaine are two such medications commonly used for these conditions. Both drugs are known as local anesthetics, which affect how nerves transmit signals to perceive sensations such as pain and itch. They work by impacting sodium ion channels in the membranes of nerve cells, and have anesthetic effects when applied topically to irritated skin. Lidocaine belongs to the amide class of anesthetics, one of two main classes of local anesthetic drugs (along with ester anesthetics). Pramoxine does not fit in either category, instead containing an ether group in its chemical structure.
Pramoxine vs lidocaine side-by-side
| Attribute | Pramoxine | Lidocaine |
|---|---|---|
| Brand Name | Analpram, ItchX, PrameGel, among others | Xylocaine, Lidoderm among others |
| Contraindications | Allergies to 'caine' anesthetics, certain blood disorders (methemoglobinemia) | Allergies to 'caine' anesthetics, certain blood disorders (methemoglobinemia) |
| Cost | $10-$30 for Pramoxine (1%) cream | $20-$40 for Lidocaine (4%) cream |
| Generic Name | Pramoxine | Lidocaine |
| Most Serious Side Effect | Allergic reactions, serious skin reactions, vision changes, systemic absorption issues | Allergic reactions, central nervous system problems, vision disturbances, heart-related symptoms |
| Severe Drug Interactions | Not specifically mentioned, but caution advised with other local anesthetics or medications that may increase methemoglobin levels | Not specifically mentioned, but caution advised with other local anesthetics or medications that may increase methemoglobin levels |
| Typical Dose | Apply 1–4 times daily, every 3–4 hours as needed | Apply every 2–3 hours as needed, up to 4 times daily |
What is pramoxine?
Pramoxine (also known as Pramocaine) is a local anesthetic that marked a significant development beyond the first classes of local anesthetics, the amino esters and amino amides. Pramoxine was first introduced in 1953, and has been used extensively for its numbing properties in topical creams and ointments. It works by stabilizing neuronal membranes to decrease permeability to sodium ions, thus decreasing depolarization and blocking transmission of nerve impulses around the site of application.
Lidocaine is another type of local anesthetic belonging to the amino amide group. Lidocaine works similarly to pramoxine, but influences both sodium ion channels and (to a lesser degree) potassium ion channels, leading to a higher potency than pramoxine.
While both are effective at relieving localized pain or discomfort from minor skin irritations, hemorrhoids, etc., they differ slightly in their side effect profiles and onset times. Lidocaine tends to have a faster onset, while pramoxine might be associated with fewer allergic reactions due its lack of cross-sensitivity with other classes of anaesthetics.
What conditions is pramoxine approved to treat?
Pramoxine is approved for the treatment of various types of pain and itching:
- Minor skin irritations
- Minor burns
- Sunburns
- Insect bites
- Hemorrhoids or other rectal discomfort
It can also be used in combination with other medications (such as corticosteroids) to treat certain conditions such as inflammatory anal dermatoses.
How does pramoxine help with these illnesses?
Pramoxine helps manage discomfort and pain by temporarily numbing the area where it's applied. It does this by stabilizing the neuronal membrane and inhibiting its depolarization, preventing the initiation and conduction of nerve impulses and thereby causing local anesthesia (numbing). Pramoxine thus helps provide temporary relief from pain or itching caused by conditions like minor skin irritations or hemorrhoids.
What is lidocaine?
Lidocaine, available under many brand names including Xylocaine and Lignocaine, is a local anesthetic that works by reducing the permeability of neuronal membranes to sodium ions, thereby reducing the conduction of pain signals to the brain. This makes it incredibly effective for numbing specific areas of the body during minor surgical procedures or for relieving discomfort associated with certain medical conditions when applied topically. Lidocaine was first approved by the FDA in 1948 and continues to be widely used today.
Lidocaine can also be given intravenously, permitting a wide range of applications including in dental procedures and for managing irregular heartbeats (arrhythmias). Its broad scope of utility combined with its strong safety profile make lidocaine an invaluable tool in both topical pain management and procedural anesthesia.
What conditions is lidocaine approved to treat?
Lidocaine is a local anesthetic that's been approved for the relief of pain associated with various conditions such as:
- Minor burns, including sunburn
- Insect bites or stings
- Minor cuts and scrapes
- Hemorrhoids and other anorectal disorders
Its numbing effects help to decrease pain and discomfort. It can also be given intravenously, which is common in dental procedures.
How does lidocaine help with these illnesses?
Lidocaine is a local anesthetic that works by blocking nerve signals in the body, providing relief from pain and discomfort. It is used in many medical procedures, including minor surgeries and dental work, and also as a topical ointment for skin irritations or conditions like shingles. Lidocaine works by inhibiting the passage of sodium ions through neuronal cell membranes, temporarily preventing the initiation and transmission of nerve impulses. This results in a numbing effect at the area where it's applied.
How effective are pramoxine and lidocaine?
Both pramoxine and lidocaine are topical anesthetic agents that have been extensively employed in managing localized pain, itching, and discomfort related to conditions such as hemorrhoids, sunburns, insect bites, etc. The mechanism of action of both drugs involves diminishing nerve signal propagation at the site of application, thus reducing sensations of pain or itching.
In terms of side effects profiles and tolerability, both medications carry minimal risks when used appropriately. However, it is important to note that hypersensitivity reactions can occur with either drug. There are more reported cases of hypersensitivity with lidocaine, but that could be because it's also widely used as an injectable local anaesthetic in addition to its topical use.
When selecting between these two options for topical anesthesia needs, since their clinical efficacy is similar, other factors such as availability and cost-effectiveness should be taken into account. Both pramoxine and lidocaine have undergone extensive pharmacological research and are reliable choices for patients needing quick relief from minor skin irritations or mild superficial pains.
Related trials for pramoxine and lidocaine
Find Top Clinical Trials
Choose from over 30,000 active clinical trials.
At what dose is pramoxine typically prescribed?
For topical applications of pramoxine, dosage ranges from 1–4 times daily, with one application every 3–4 hours being sufficient for managing pain and itching in most people. Children may also use pramoxine under adult supervision. In either population, if there is no response after a few days of treatment, medical advice should be sought.
At what dose is lidocaine typically prescribed?
Lidocaine typically comes in concentrations of 1–5% in a cream or gel, and is applied to the affected area every 2–3 hours as needed. The maximum dose is 4 applications daily, depending on the severity of symptoms and how well they respond to initial treatment. It's important not to exceed the maximum application guidelines, which is around 40 g of lidocaine per day for an adult, spread over no more than half of the surface area of the body. For children, dosage will vary depending on their size and weight, so it's crucial that a physician determines appropriate usage parameters for children. If there is no response or symptoms wrosen after a few days of consistent use, consult with your healthcare provider.
What are the most common side effects of pramoxine?
Common side effects of pramoxine may include:
- Mild burning, stinging, or itching where the medicine is applied
- Drowsiness or dizziness
- Dryness at the area of application
If any of these symptoms persist after using pramoxine, it is advisable to seek medical assistance promptly.
Are there any potential serious side effects for pramoxine?
While pramoxine is typically a safe and effective topical anesthetic, there are potentially serious side effects to be aware of:
- Signs of allergic reaction: hives; difficulty breathing; swelling in your face, lips, tongue or throat. If you experience any of these symptoms after using pramoxine, seek immediate medical attention.
- Serious skin reactions such as blisters or peeling are extremely rare but should be brought to the attention of a healthcare professional immediately.
- Vision changes such as blurred vision could indicate an adverse reaction. If this occurs, discontinue use and consult a doctor.
- While very unlikely with topical application, systemic absorption leading to a fast heartbeat or feeling like you might pass out would require immediate medical attention.
- Changes in muscle tone, like stiffness (rigidity) in muscles indicates a rare but serious reaction. Stop usage and get emergency help promptly if this happens.
Always remember that it's crucial to follow the recommended dosage instructions when using medications like pramoxine to minimize risks associated with overuse or misuse.
What are the most common side effects of lidocaine?
Lidocaine can cause the following mild side effects:
- Mild skin irritation at the application site
- Nausea or vomiting (if swallowed)
- Ringing in your ears or dizziness
- Drowsiness
- Feeling nervous or anxious
- Rash or other allergic reactions such as hives
Remember that lidocaine is meant for topical use only. If ingested orally by accident, it may lead to more serious side effects like seizures. Always follow directions on the packaging and consult your healthcare provider if you experience any of these symptoms.
Are there any potential serious side effects for lidocaine?
While lidocaine is generally safe, it's important to be aware of potentially serious side effects, which can include:
- Signs of allergic reaction or severe skin reaction: hives, itching, fever, swollen glands, difficulty breathing, or swelling in your face or throat
- Uncommon but serious central nervous system problems, such as seizures (convulsions), confusion, and unusual changes in mood or behavior
- Vision disturbances such as blurred vision, tunnel vision, and seeing halos around lights
- Heart-related symptoms like a fast or irregular heartbeat
If you experience any of these symptoms while using lidocaine, seek immediate medical attention. It's also critical to note that although it's rare, overuse of topical anesthetics like lidocaine can lead to a condition called methemoglobinemia (which can lead to a blue hue in the skin among other effects), which requires urgent treatment.
Contraindications for pramoxine and lidocaine
Both pramoxine and lidocaine are local anesthetics used to numb specific areas of the body to decrease pain or discomfort. If you notice your symptoms worsening or experience any adverse reactions such as abnormal redness, swelling, or increased pain at the site of application, please seek immediate medical attention.
Neither pramoxine nor lidocaine should be used if you have certain blood disorders (methemoglobinemia), allergies to other '-caine' anesthetics (e.g., benzocaine), or a history of allergic reaction to either medication. It's crucial that your doctor is made aware of all other medications you're currently taking and any known allergies, as some drugs can interact negatively with these topical anesthetics, causing serious conditions like methemoglobinemia.
Avoid applying these anesthetics on broken skin or across large areas of the body unless directed by your healthcare professional. Over-application could lead to absorption into the bloodstream, resulting in unwanted side effects such as irregular heartbeat, nervous system problems, etc.
How much do pramoxine and lidocaine cost?
For the brand name versions of these drugs:
- The price of a 42.5 g tube of pramoxine (1%) cream averages around $15–$30, which works out to approximately $0.35–$0.70 per day, depending on your dose and how often you apply it.
- The price for a similar amount (50 g) of lidocaine (4%) cream averages about $20–$40, working out to roughly $0.40–$0.80 per day, again depending on how often its applied and the size of the area to be covered.
Thus, brand-name pramoxine may be slightly less expensive than branded lidocaine on a per-day treatment basis. Please note that cost should not be the primary consideration in determining which of these topical anesthetics is right for you.
For the generic versions of pramoxine and lidocaine creams, costs can be slightly lower:
- Generic pramoxine (1% cream) is available at prices starting from as low as $10 for larger tubes, reducing daily costs significantly relative to brand-name equivalents.
- Similarly priced generic options exist for lidocaine, as well.
Popularity of pramoxine and lidocaine
Pramoxine, available in generic form and under various brand names, is a local anesthetic commonly used to relieve pain and itching caused by minor skin irritations, burns, insect bites, and hemorrhoids. In 2020, it was estimated that pramoxine was prescribed or recommended over-the-counter (OTC) to millions of people in the US. The prevalence of pramoxine has been fairly stable over the last decade.
Lidocaine, including brand versions such as Lidoderm and Xylocaine, is also a local anesthetic often used in topical applications. It's also frequently utilized during minor surgeries or dental procedures to numb tissue in a specific area (local anesthesia), to relieve nerve pain (especially after shingles infection; post-herpetic neuralgia), and to manage irregular heartbeat (arrhythmia), among other uses. Lidocaine accounted for a significant percentage of local anesthetic prescriptions in the USA throughout 2020, with its use remaining steady over recent years.
Conclusion
Both pramoxine and lidocaine are topical anesthetics used for relieving itching or skin irritation. Both medications have been extensively studied, and have demonstrated efficacy. They work through a similar mechanism of action by blocking the transmission of nerve impulses in the area where they're applied, though they're sometimes utilized in different circumstances due to slight differences in potency and duration of effect.
Lidocaine is often chosen when stronger anesthesia is required as it's more potent than pramoxine, while pramoxine may be preferred for less severe symptoms or for people who need to avoid certain side-effects sometimes associated with lidocaine such as burning or stinging at the application site.
Both drugs can be purchased over-the-counter, which allows for easy access. Generic versions are available for both lidocaine and pramoxine, offering substantial cost savings for those paying out-of-pocket. Pramoxine tends to act quickly but its effects don't last as long as those of lidocaine, which takes slightly longer to take effect but lasts longer.
The side-effect profiles of the two drugs are comparable. Both products are generally well-tolerated, although users should seek immediate medical attention if they experience any unusual reactions like an irregular heartbeat or difficulty breathing.
Other Trials to Consider
Popular Categories
Popular Guides
Learn More About These Treatments
Refrences
- Chou, A.-K., Chiu, C.-C., Chen, Y.-W., Wang, J.-J., & Hung, C.-H. (2018, December). Skin nociceptive block with pramoxine delivery by subcutaneous injection in rats. Pharmacological Reports. Springer Science and Business Media LLC.http://doi.org/10.1016/j.pharep.2018.09.001
- Bonanno, P. C. (1994, May). Safe Dosages of Lidocaine for Facial Analgesia. Journal of Craniofacial Surgery. Ovid Technologies (Wolters Kluwer Health).http://doi.org/10.1097/00001665-199405000-00016