Your session is about to expire
Fibercon vs Metamucil
Introduction
For patients dealing with constipation or looking to increase their dietary fiber intake, certain supplements can aid in improving bowel regularity and overall digestive health. Fibercon and Metamucil are two such products that are often recommended for these purposes. They each contain different types of fiber, but both assist in adding bulk to the stool which helps stimulate bowel movements. Fibercon contains a type of synthetic fiber known as polycarbophil calcium, which is not fermentable and does not cause gas or bloating like some other fibers may do. On the other hand, Metamucil is made from natural psyllium husk fiber, which absorbs water in your gut to form a soft gel-like substance that promotes smoother bowel movements while also offering additional benefits such as lowering cholesterol levels and controlling blood sugar levels for people with Type 2 diabetes.
Fibercon vs Metamucil Side By Side
| Attribute | Fibercon | Metamucil |
|---|---|---|
| Brand Name | Fibercon | Metamucil |
| Contraindications | Difficulty swallowing, bowel obstruction | Difficulty swallowing, bowel obstruction |
| Cost | Approximately $0.14–$0.28/day for brand name, $.06 - $.12 per day for generic | Approximately $0.22/day for brand name, below $.20 cents per day for generic |
| Generic Name | Polycarbophil | Psyllium |
| Most Serious Side Effect | Allergic reactions, such as hives, difficulty breathing or swallowing, swelling in your face or throat | Allergic reactions, such as rash, itching/swelling (especially of the face/tongue/throat), severe dizziness, trouble breathing |
| Severe Drug Interactions | Minimal interference with absorption of nutrients or medications, but always consult with a healthcare provider | Can slow down the absorption of certain medications, so it's best to take it at least two hours before or after other medications |
| Typical Dose | 2–4 caplets per day, starting with 1 caplet and adjusting as needed | One rounded tablespoon (approximately 3.4 grams) once per day, can be increased to up to three times daily |
What is Fibercon?
Fibercon (the generic name being Polycarbophil) is a laxative that aids in treating constipation and maintaining bowel regularity. It is a form of fiber that absorbs water in the intestines and forms a soft, bulky stool, making bowel movements easier. Fibercon was approved by the FDA in 1968. It works by increasing the bulk in your diet, hence giving a feeling of fullness and stimulating bowel movements.
On the other hand, Metamucil (Psyllium) is a natural fiber that is used to treat constipation as well. It absorbs liquid in the intestines, swells, and forms a bulky stool, which is easy to pass. While both Fibercon and Metamucil work to alleviate constipation, they differ in their primary active ingredients. Metamucil’s primary ingredient, Psyllium, has a more potent effect, resulting in it having a stronger laxative effect compared to Fibercon. However, this also means that Metamucil may cause more side effects, such as bloating and gas.
What conditions is Fibercon approved to treat?
Fibercon (Calcium Polycarbophil) is used to treat various gastrointestinal conditions, including:
- Constipation
- Irritable bowel syndrome
- Diverticulosis
On the other hand, Metamucil (Psyllium) is a bulk-forming fiber laxative approved for:
- Control and relief of constipation
- Management of irritable bowel syndrome
- Lowering cholesterol when combined with diet.
How does Fibercon help with these illnesses?
Fibercon assists in managing constipation by introducing more bulk into the stool, which helps to stimulate the muscles of the bowel to pass waste more efficiently. It achieves this by using calcium polycarbophil, a type of fiber that absorbs water in the intestine and swells, creating a softer and larger stool that moves more readily through the digestive tract. Fiber is a type of carbohydrate that the body can't digest, and it plays a crucial role in digestion, heart health, weight management, and more. It is believed that individuals with constipation may lack fiber in their diet. Therefore, by increasing fiber intake with Fibercon, individuals can aid in relieving the discomfort of constipation and promote healthier bowel movements.
What is Metamucil?
Metamucil, a well-known brand for psyllium husk, is a type of dietary fiber supplement that acts by increasing the bulk in your stool. This natural process helps promote movement of material through your digestive system, aiding regular bowel movements. First approved for over-the-counter use in the 1930s, Metamucil can help reduce constipation and promote general digestive health. Unlike Fibercon, Metamucil is not a synthetic fiber, meaning it is derived from a plant source. While it does not inhibit absorption of nutrients, it can slow down the absorption of certain medications, so it's best to take it at least two hours before or after other medications. Its primary side effects are generally mild and can include bloating and gas. As Metamucil expands and absorbs water in the digestive tract, it can aid in weight control by creating a feeling of fullness. It may be more suitable for those who prefer a more natural approach to maintaining digestive health compared to synthetic products like Fibercon.
What conditions is Metamucil approved to treat?
Metamucil is a fiber supplement approved for usage to provide the following benefits:
- Relief of occasional constipation and irregularity
- Lowering cholesterol to promote heart health
- Maintaining healthy blood sugar levels as part of your diet
- Promoting overall digestive health
How does Metamucil help with these illnesses?
Psyllium, the main ingredient in Metamucil, is a type of fiber that acts as a bulk-forming laxative, increasing the amount of water in your stool to make it softer and easier to pass. This action can help alleviate symptoms of constipation and promote regular bowel movements. Psyllium also plays a role in improving overall digestive health, as it can help to maintain the health of the gut lining and promote the growth of beneficial gut bacteria. Unlike Fibercon, which mainly acts as a stool softener, Metamucil offers multiple benefits for digestive health. Its action on gut motility and gut bacteria may also play roles in the action of Metamucil as a digestive aid. Since it has a broader range of effects, it is sometimes chosen when a patient does not respond well to the "typical" stool softeners (such as Fibercon), or may be combined with them.
How effective are both Fibercon and Metamucil?
Both Fibercon (Polycarbophil) and Metamucil (Psyllium) are well-recognized names in the management of constipation, with both being available over-the-counter for several decades. They work through different mechanisms; Polycarbophil is a synthetic fiber that absorbs water to form a soft, bulky stool, while Psyllium is a natural fiber that works similarly but also has some additional effects on cholesterol levels.
The effectiveness of Fibercon and Metamucil was studied directly in a double-blind clinical trial where both were found to be effective at easing symptoms of constipation. The study did not find significant differences between them regarding their capacity to alleviate these symptoms. It should be noted though, there have been few direct comparative studies between these two treatments.
A 2005 review detailed the effectiveness of Polycarbophil starting from the first couple days of treatment, offering favorable tolerability among many users due to its minimal interference with absorption of nutrients or medications. This makes it an ideal option for elderly populations who often take multiple medications daily.
In contrast, psyllium's mechanism offers benefits beyond just treating constipation: it can help lower LDL ("bad") cholesterol levels when used as part of diet low in saturated fat and cholesterol. Despite this advantage however psyllium may interact more frequently with other drugs compared to polycarbophil by delaying their absorption rate.
Nonetheless, because they act differently within the body’s digestive system each person might respond better or prefer one over another depending on personal factors such as lifestyle habits or concurrent medical conditions.
Find Top Clinical Trials
Choose from over 30,000 active clinical trials.
At what dose is Fibercon typically prescribed?
Dosages for Fibercon (calcium polycarbophil) range from 2–4 caplets per day, but clinical practice has shown that 2 caplets per day is sufficient for treating constipation in most individuals. Adolescents and adults may be started on a lower dose of 1 caplet per day. If there is no response after a few days, the dosage can be increased gradually to up to 4 caplets daily divided into two doses. Conversely, dosages for Metamucil (Psyllium husk) usually start at one rounded teaspoon mixed with water once or twice per day and can also be adjusted as needed based on individual response. As always, it's important not to exceed the maximum recommended dosage mentioned on the product label unless advised by your healthcare provider.
At what dose is Metamucil typically prescribed?
Metamucil treatment is typically initiated at a dosage of one rounded tablespoon (approximately 3.4 grams) once per day. The dose can be gradually increased to up to three times daily, if necessary. Each dose should be mixed with 8 ounces of water or any other cool liquid, and consumed promptly. It's essential that each dose is followed by an additional glass of liquid to ensure the product reaches the stomach properly. If there's no improvement in bowel regularity or feelings of fullness after using Metamucil for a week, it might be worthwhile discussing further options with your doctor.
What are the most common side effects for Fibercon?
While comparing Fibercon to Metamucil, a few common side effects can be expected:
- Gas and bloating
- Stomach cramps or discomfort
- Nausea or vomiting
- Mild constipation or diarrhea
- Feeling full after consuming only a small amount
- Choking (if not taken with enough liquid)
Always remember to take fiber supplements with plenty of water. If you experience severe abdominal pain, rectal bleeding, persistent constipation/diarrhea or any other severe symptoms while taking these products, seek immediate medical attention.
Are there any potential serious side effects for Fibercon?
While Fibercon and Metamucil are both fiber supplements designed to alleviate constipation, they can have different side effects. For instance:
- Allergic reactions: Signs of an allergic reaction may include hives, difficulty breathing or swallowing, swelling in your face or throat. If you experience these symptoms after taking either supplement, seek immediate medical help.
- Digestive problems: Both supplements can cause bloating, gas and stomach cramping. They might also worsen constipation if not taken with sufficient water.
- Changes in bowel habits: You may notice changes in the color, consistency or frequency of your bowel movements while taking these supplements.
- Choking hazard: If not swallowed with plenty of water, both Fibercon and Metamucil could swell up in the throat potentially causing choking.
Always remember that it's advisable to start any new medication under a healthcare professional's guidance who can monitor for potential adverse reactions.
What are the most common side effects for Metamucil?
When considering Metamucil, there are possible side effects you should be aware of:
- Minor bloating or gas
- Mild stomach cramps
- Feelings of fullness in the stomach
- An allergic reaction such as rash, itching/swelling (especially of the face/tongue/throat)
- Severe dizziness
- Trouble breathing.
Remember that these symptoms are less likely if you consume plenty of water with your dose. As with all medications, it's essential to discuss any concerns with your healthcare provider before starting a new regimen.
Are there any potential serious side effects for Metamucil?
While Metamucil is generally safe when used as directed, it can occasionally cause some side effects. It's important to be aware of these and monitor for them:
- Signs of an allergic reaction: hives, itching, difficulty breathing or swallowing, swelling in your face or throat
- Excessive bloating or gas
- Sudden changes in bowel habits lasting more than two weeks
- Constipation that lasts more than seven days
- Severe stomach pain
- Unusual bleeding from the rectum or unusually dark stools
If you experience any of these symptoms after taking Metamucil, stop using it immediately and seek medical attention.
Contraindications for Fibercon and Metamucil?
Both Fibercon and Metamucil, like most fiber supplements, may cause bloating or gas in some people. If you notice these symptoms becoming severe or persisting over time, please consult your healthcare professional.
Neither Fibercon nor Metamucil should be taken if you have difficulty swallowing or have been diagnosed with a bowel obstruction. Always inform your physician about all the medications and dietary supplements you are taking; certain drugs can interfere with the absorption of nutrients when taken together with fiber supplements.
It's also important to increase your water intake while using these products as they work by absorbing water in the intestines to form a softer bulkier stool. Not drinking enough fluids could lead to constipation instead of relieving it.
Lastly, remember that sudden changes in diet can disrupt your body’s digestive system. Therefore, when starting on either Fibercon or Metamucil, it is recommended to gradually increase your dosage over several days to allow your body time to adjust.
How much do Fibercon and Metamucil cost?
For the brand name versions of these drugs:
- The price of 140 caplets of FiberCon (625 mg) averages around $20 which works out to approximately $0.14–$0.28/day, depending on your dose.
- The price for a container of Metamucil powder (114 doses at 3.4 grams per dose) is about $25, working out to roughly $0.22/day.
Thus, if you are in the higher dosage range for FiberCon (i.e., four caplets per day), then brand-name Metamucil is less expensive on a per-day treatment basis. However, it's important to note that cost should not be the primary consideration when determining which fiber supplement is right for you.
In regards to generic versions:
- A comparable store-brand version of Fibercon can cost as low as $10 for 160 tablets, resulting in costs from about $.06 - $.12 per day depending on your daily dosage.
- Generic psyllium husk powder similar to Metamucil can range around $16 for a supply lasting over three months with typical use, leading to an even lower daily cost below $.20 cents per day.
Popularity of Fibercon and Metamucil
Fiber supplements are commonly used for the treatment of constipation, and two well-known brands are Fibercon (polycarbophil) and Metamucil (psyllium).
Polycarbophil, sold under brand names like Fibercon, is a synthetic fiber that acts by absorbing water in the intestines to form a softer bulkier stool. Its use has stayed relatively consistent over recent years with an estimated 1 million people in the U.S using it annually.
Psyllium, marketed as Metamucil among others, is a natural dietary fiber derived from Plantago ovata seeds husks. It also absorbs water within your gut to soften your stool and increase its bulk. Psyllium has been consistently popular due to its natural origins and additional heart health benefits associated with soluble fibers; approximately 3 million people in the US regularly take psyllium-based products such as Metamucil each year. Over time, there's been an upward trend in psyllium usage driven by growing interest in functional foods and holistic wellness.
Conclusion
Both Fibercon (calcium polycarbophil) and Metamucil (psyllium) have been widely used for many years in the management of constipation, with numerous clinical studies indicating that they are more effective than placebo treatments. They work differently: Fibercon is a synthetic fiber supplement that absorbs water to form a soft, bulky stool, while Metamucil is a natural bulk-forming laxative made from psyllium husk which also works by absorbing liquid in the intestines.
Fibercon can be an option when individuals need to avoid fermentable fibers due to conditions like IBS or excessive gas since it does not ferment in the intestinal tract. On the other hand, Metamucil has additional health benefits such as lowering cholesterol levels and controlling blood sugar levels in people with type 2 diabetes.
Both supplements are available over-the-counter, offering significant cost savings especially for patients who must pay out of pocket. The effects of both may take some time to become noticeable; users should use them consistently as directed on the label or by their healthcare provider.
The side effect profile is similar between these two dietary supplements; they're generally well-tolerated but can cause minor gastrointestinal issues such as bloating and gas. As always, if you experience any adverse effects or your symptoms persist despite treatment, seek medical advice promptly.